
Josef Boni
Brand Strategist
Over 20 years manufacturing and retailing ice cream in Edinburgh, followed by senior sales and technical director roles. Josef has judged nationally for over 40 years, including as head judge at the Royal Highland Show.
The Golden Scoop Awards are organised by the Ice Cream Alliance. Our job is simple: judge fairly, feed back honestly, and give great ice cream a mark that customers understand.
The Ice Cream Alliance is the UK trade association for ice cream makers, retailers and mobilers. For over eight decades the Alliance has been dedicated to one simple mission: growing and supporting the ice cream industry. From small artisan makers to large scale producers, the goal has always been to help businesses thrive and to bring more people into this vibrant trade.
The Golden Scoop Awards are how that mission shows up in a tub. Each entry is judged and accredited with a 1 to 5 star rating, helping your ice cream stand out from competitors and giving consumers confidence in their choice. A star rating builds trust with customers and works as a marketing tool that can directly boost sales.
Ice cream is bought on trust. A shopper standing in front of a freezer cabinet has no way of knowing which tub took months of recipe work and which was bought in. An independent, blind judged rating closes that gap. It rewards the producers doing the hard work and gives customers a reason to choose them.
Recognition is given at both regional and national levels, ensuring excellence is celebrated across the UK. And for one outstanding entrant, the highest honour awaits: the coveted Golden Scoop National Champion title, reserved for an ice cream maker who demonstrates exceptional skill, consistency and all round excellence.
The awards are not only a competition. Every entrant, whether they win or not, receives a full breakdown of how their product was scored: the marks for appearance, texture and flavour, and score graphs showing exactly where the product sat against its class. That is far more useful than a rosette.
Producers act on it. Recipes get adjusted, textures get refined, and entries come back stronger the following year. Over successive competitions that compounds into something bigger than any single result, which is a measurable lift in the quality of ice cream being made across Britain and Ireland. Raising the standard of the trade is the point of the Alliance, and the Golden Scoop feedback is one of the most direct ways it happens.
Every sample is judged blind. Tubs arrive with a pre applied label and nothing else. Judges do not know which business made which sample, and scores are recorded independently before any total is calculated. Entrants who mark their tubs in any way are disqualified, because anonymity is the whole basis of the result.
Entries are scored by two panels of four. Each judge marks out of 100 points, so every sample carries a maximum score of 400. Panels assess complete classes so that comparisons within a class are always like for like.

Brand Strategist
Over 20 years manufacturing and retailing ice cream in Edinburgh, followed by senior sales and technical director roles. Josef has judged nationally for over 40 years, including as head judge at the Royal Highland Show.

ICA Gelato Chef
A master gelato maker, entrepreneur and consultant based in London. His Salted Amaretto was crowned Best UK Flavour at the Gelato Festival World Masters in 2021.

Food Application Specialist
Bringing over 45 years of hands on industry experience, Ruth has led the development and launch of hundreds of retail and foodservice products, working on technically complex formulations where sensory performance is critical. This breadth of experience underpins her understanding of the balance between innovation and consistency that defines award winning ice cream.
Gelato Chef & Specialist
Antonio Catalano brings authentic Italian expertise, with extensive experience in gelato production, formulation and techniques, working with two of Italy’s leading flavour houses delivering exceptional dessert solutions.
Photo to follow
National Technical Manager, Antonelli
Known across the trade as Gelato Jonny. Bologna trained in advanced gelato making and head of the Gelato Academy, with over a decade of hands on technical experience.
Profile to follow
Ariela’s full profile will be published here shortly.
Photo and bio to follow
ICA Technical & Legislative Consultant
Over 25 years in the food industry across development, technical and process development, from practical product applications to board level appointments. Simon has worked with the Ice Cream Alliance for the last ten years.

Lead Product Developer for Frozen, Marks & Spencer
As Lead Product Developer for Frozen at Marks & Spencer, Laurie has been integral to transforming the ice cream range, for which she drew on both flavour and nostalgia for inspiration.